The scientists worked with 36 dogs in their own homes and videotaped the owners ignoring them in favor of a stuffed, animated dog or a jack-o-lantern pail. In both these conditions, the owners were instructed to treat the objects as though they were real dogs – petting them, talking to them sweetly, etc.
In the third scenario, the owners were asked to read aloud a pop-up book that played melodies. The dogs’ behavior was then analyzed for aggression, attention seeking, and/or interest in the owner or object. Dogs were about twice as likely to push or touch the owner when the owner was interacting with the faux dog (78 %) as when the owner was attending to the pail (42 %). Even fewer (22 %) did this in the book condition. About 30 % of the dogs also tried to get between their owner and the stuffed animal. And while 25 % snapped at the ‘other dog,’ only one did so at the pail and book.